Working together to better prevent deaths across places of detention
Wendy Sinclair-Gieben, Chair of the Independent Advisory Panel on Deaths in Detention, has shared her reflections on her first six months in the role.
Nearly 6 months into my role as Chair of the Independent Advisory Panel on Deaths in Detention, I continue to be excited for the change we can help bring to detention settings. Before taking up my post in May 2026, I was impressed that England and Wales had developed and funded an independent advisory panel focused on reducing preventable deaths in detention. To me, it was a visible demonstration of a genuine commitment to learning, accountability and saving lives. Happily, I discovered that I inherited not only an expert and impressive Panel, but also a high-calibre team supporting its work.
Since taking up the role, it has been very striking to see the evidence and data available to the Panel from across all the detention settings. In some areas, there are grounds for encouragement. I welcome recent decreases in self-inflicted deaths in prison custody, for example, and that some settings such as immigration detention continue to record relatively low numbers of deaths.
At the same time, there are areas of real concern. I continue to be troubled by the rise in homicides in prisons and by increases in police-related deaths. I was also surprised by the number of deaths among those supervised by probation services, most of which fall outside the Panel’s remit, but which should worry us all.
Other issues stood out to me. I remain surprised that mental health detention does not always have the same approach to investigating deaths as in police custody, prisons or immigration detention. I welcomed the important research the Panel is taking forward on issues such as the use of force, Prevention of Future Deaths reports arising from prison deaths, and approaches to family liaison. I look forward to presenting this evidence-led advice to Ministers and officials in the coming months.
Looking ahead, I am keen to strengthen relationships across all UK jurisdictions. England and Wales are part of a wider family, and detention settings across the UK often face similar challenges. Where good practice has been developed, we should be learning from one another and sharing that learning as widely as possible. I hope to further strengthen links with colleagues in Scotland and Northern Ireland, and to build wider relationships with other jurisdictions over time.
I have also taken up this role at a time of change. Following a Cabinet Office review of all similar bodies across Government, Ministers have decided to make changes to the Ministerial Board on Deaths in Custody. Seeking to reflect the range of detention settings covered – including mental health and immigration detention – it is being renamed the Ministerial Board on Deaths in Detention, rather than simply custody. In consultation with my Panel members, I have taken the decision to take the same approach. My Panel will be renamed the Independent Advisory Panel on Deaths in Detention as well.
The composition of the Board has also changed. Its key stakeholders now form a separate Expert Stakeholder Group (ESG), providing advice and assistance to the Board. The Board itself now comprises Ministers, officials, detention setting leads, and my Panel. We will be working closely with Board members – with the help of our ESG – to identify priority areas and develop advice that we hope will lead to impactful work to reduce deaths. We also have the opportunity to expand our range of stakeholders to ensure the ESG represents the full range of expertise and experience relevant to deaths in detention.
But these changes will only be successful if they help detention settings reduce deaths. I hope that the streamlined focus of the reformed Board enables it to take impactful decisions to do so. And fundamentally, this work is not about structures, but about people. It is about learning from tragedy, understanding risk, supporting those most vulnerable, and doing everything possible to prevent future deaths.
Regardless of these changes, the Panel will continue to provide independent advice and constructive challenge. We will continue to champion learning, hold a mirror up to the system where needed, and keep stakeholders, bereaved families and those with lived experience at the heart of our work.
I have been encouraged by the first meetings with our stakeholders on the ESG. Their input to the emerging priorities we are developing with the Board has been vital. Following our discussions, my Panel is particularly keen to explore the following areas:
- Transitions between detention and liberty, as well as between detention settings.
- Information-sharing, particularly in the context of healthcare.
- Progress against recommendations across detention settings.
- Improving how we understand and address risk.
My first few months as Chair have been both enlightening and rewarding. There will undoubtedly be challenges ahead. But I am optimistic about what can be achieved when we work together with a shared purpose. I am excited to continue that work.